For well over a decade, MHProNews has had a tagline under its logo that proclaimed: “Industry News, Tips and Views Pros Can Use.” © That logo appears on nearly every public-facing page on the MHProNews website. During the 16 years that this platform has operated, MHProNews has focused on HUD Code manufactured housing while providing a periodic mix of political, economic, social, spiritual, research, media, tech, and broader U.S. or even global news items that provide professionals a context for the dynamics at play that manufactured housing operates in. Restated, there is no one factor that has kept manufactured home production at the historic lows of the 21st century. Rather, there is a mosaic of circumstances that our profession operates in which helps explain why our profession is mired at levels that were not seen since the late 1950s or early 1960s when the population was far smaller (see that article among the headlines for the week in review in Part III for details). That includes this “prologue” the first in a periodic series about the “The Long Shadow of Billionaire Warren Buffett over Manufactured Housing and Affordable Housing Crisis.” As this facts-evidence-analysis (FEA) will outline, as important as understanding centi-billionaire Warren Buffett’s shadow over manufactured housing and the affordable housing crisis is, one should not over or under emphasize his role and that of others like him to properly understand the doldrums our profession operates in. With the memory of the “No Kings” day protests fresh in mind (see that article in Part III), the Capital Research Center (CRC) “Infiltrated” research (see Part III) on the “Ideological Capture of Homeless Advocacy” (see Part III), clearly billionaires and the nonprofits they fund is a factor in U.S. society. There are multiple dynamics at play in MHVille, including the new Manufactured Housing Institute (MHI) board member Sam Landy (see Part III). Third-party artificial intelligence (AI) has confirmed as recently as yesterday (see Part III) that no one in our profession covers manufactured housing industry news in the same way that MHProNews does. That may explain why September 2025 witnessed a record 1.8 million visitors to this site, and for the second month in a row, MHProNews has had over 1 million visitors per server data provided by Webalizer. Which brings us to the second part of the headline, what some in mainstream media, academia, and politics have described as the soft second civil war underway in the U.S.
The prologue for Buffett’s Shadow will be in Part II.
Part I. Is the U.S. in a Soft Civil War?
1) Citing audio provided by left-leaning NPR (provided below), right-leaning Breitbart provided this partial transcript shown below.
Quoting Breitbart in an article entitled “DE Gov. Meyer: We Could ‘End the Shutdown and Fund Programs Like SNAP’, But ‘We’ve Got to Fight’ on Health Care,” reporter Ian Hatchnet wrote this.
On Friday’s broadcast of NPR’s “Morning Edition,” Delaware Gov. Matt Meyer (D) said that “lawmakers could decide to end the shutdown and fund programs like SNAP so governors like myself don’t have this problem.”
Per that Breitbart article.
“lawmakers could decide to end the shutdown and fund programs like SNAP so governors like myself don’t have this problem. But then we’re going to have another huge problem” on health care. And said, “I appreciate that Democratic legislators are fighting, and we’ve got to fight.”
Again, according to Breitbart.
Meyer said, [relevant remarks begin around 3:30] “I recognize that this stalemate in Washington is largely about health care. And, right now, lawmakers could decide to end the shutdown and fund programs like SNAP so governors like myself don’t have this problem. But then we’re going to have another huge problem that healthcare premiums will be doubling for millions of Americans. So, these are all self-inflicted crises. And, in a wealthy country like ours, we’ve got to find a better way.”
NPR co-host A Martínez asked: “Just a few moments left, Governor, how do you square that with your constituents when they ask you, like, why is this happening? What do you tell them?” Democratic Governor Meyer replied as follows.
“Well, first of all, I tell my constituents you’re going to eat, you’re going to have food benefits that we’ve had for as long as the SNAP program has existed. So, I tell them my job and our job as state leaders is to protect you. In terms of what’s going on in Washington, listen, there’s a Republican executive. There’s a Republican president, President Trump. There’s a Republican legislature. The courts — Supreme Court is largely controlled by the Republican Party. This is the direction the country’s going in now. It’s not the direction that I want it to go in. I appreciate that Democratic legislators are fighting, and we’ve got to fight. But while we’re fighting, we’ve got to make sure that people can eat.”
2) In our Saturday 11.1.2025 report entitled “Time has Come for Action Over Posturing and Words. SNAP. Federal Employees. MHARR. MHI Board Member. MHI and U.S. Affordable Housing Crisis. House-Senate-President Trump Must Act. MHVille FEA” (see Part II) there are quotes from other prominent Democrats. They have made it plain in their own words that SNAP benefits are “leverage.” Much of the predicate for that “fight” by Democratic officials and legislators is based on their claim that President Trump is acting like a king, a dictator, a new fascist authoritarian in the mold of Adolf Hitler. The X post below features a video clip from left-leaning (i.e.: routinely more pro-Democratic) MSNBC.
WATCH: Democrats pretend they’ve never compared Trump to Hitler… Yet here’s Rep. Dan Goldman (D) saying President Trump wants to “become a Vladimir Putin or an Adolf Hitler or Kim Jong Un.”
These people are completely unhinged
They FEAR Trump because he’s exposing them.… pic.twitter.com/bKJeuboHIF— (@MAGA_MARA_) October 28, 2025
Fake News MSNBC: “I don’t think any Democrat has called Trump Hitler…”
Here are two minutes straight of Democrat leaders comparing Trump to Hitler and Nazis pic.twitter.com/vQx3K3D1UN
— Libs of TikTok (@libsoftiktok) October 27, 2025
Wow. Democrats are still calling President Trump Hitler:
Neil Cavuto: “Are you envisioning [Trump] as another Hitler — is that what you’re saying?”
Jim Clyburn: “That’s exactly what I’m saying!”
Cavuto: “You don’t think that’s a little hyperbolic?”
Clyburn: “You may think… pic.twitter.com/gm3ver1qC9
— Steve Cortes (@CortesSteve) November 16, 2024
THREAD: In recent weeks, Democrats and legacy media called Donald Trump Hitler and branded half the country that supports him as Nazis.
Hillary Clinton started by saying Trump and his supporters were “reenacting” a 1939 Nazi rally at Madison Square Garden. pic.twitter.com/88CwWiu1eg
— KanekoaTheGreat (@KanekoaTheGreat) October 28, 2024
3) Much of the above might have been adapted from the “two minutes of hate” pulled from the pages of George Orwell’s fictional classic 1984. Repeating a claim over and over is how some group can exaggerate or entirely fictionalize (the “Big Lie” or “Illusory Truth” effect) some claim and make it seem real. Recall this prior thread between MHProNews and Copilot that illustrates those points.
Senate Democrats have voted down a clean CR thirteen times, putting politics over safety and straining the very airport resources that keep our skies secure for millions of travelers. pic.twitter.com/kOKCU2Q4nd
— Congressman Ben Cline (@RepBenCline) October 24, 2025
4) As was noted in the preface, ideally, no one factor should be over or under stated. But to grasp what is occurring in the U.S., some more headlines from sources across the left-right divide are warranted.
5) From left-leaning Politico: “Nearly 42 Million Americans Lose their Food Stamp Benefits.”
6) From a headline on the left-leaning Prospect.org (The American Prospect or TAP) home page (at about 3:29 AM ET 11.2.2025).
- Trump’s Armed Force to Take Over Democratic Cities Is Nearly Ready to Deploy
- Trump Is Illegally Withholding Food From Needy Families
-
To Stop Trump, Unions Need Joint Campaigns and a Shared Vision
We have to be clear-eyed: Our labor movement isn’t in fighting shape. It must build up to strike readiness through greater organizing and collaboration by large locals and labor councils, and through escalating direct actions involving members and non-members alike.
7) From the home page of left-leaning and openly pro-socialist Jacobin.com (at about 3:33 AM ET 11.2.2025)
- Mamdani Can Learn From Latin American Municipal Socialism
- Humanity Needs Democratic Control of AI
- The Labor Movement Needs a Collective Anti-Trump Strategy
- The Forgotten History of Socialism and the Occult “Socialism has a well-earned reputation as a secular, rational movement. But not all socialists throughout history were quite so grounded.”
- It’s Still Possible to Rebuild a Working-Class Majority “Labor organizing can’t succeed at scale without a supportive legal and political environment, created by majoritarian coalitions that can win reforms, confront corporate power, and prove to skeptical workers that progressive governance delivers.”
8) From right-leaning Breitbart home page on 11.2.2025 (circa 3:40 AM ET).
- Illinois Passes Law Preventing ICE Arrests in Courthouses
- Climate Doomer Harrison Ford: Trump ‘Greatest Criminal in History,’ ‘Scares the Sh*t Out of Me’
- [Left-leaning Bill] Maher: Dems Still Seem to Ignore Blue-Collar Workers
- [Democratic lawmaker] Raskin: Trump Like an ‘Authoritarian Steamroller’
- [Democratic Senator Amy] Klobuchar: Trump Is Using Starving People as ‘Bargaining Chips’
- Trump: ‘I Do NOT Want Americans to Go Hungry’ — Seeks Way to Pay SNAP, Gives Out [Senate Democratic Minority Leader Chuck] Schumer’s Number
9) Via X, former left-leaning CNN host Chris Cuomo (brother of former Democratic New York Governor Andrew Cuomo).
Chris Cuomo declares the Democrat Party is DEAD 💀
Cuomo tells me elitism, open borders, socialism and defund the police killed the modern Democrat Party.
Cuomo says the Democratic Party that his father was apart of “no longer exists” and he “doesn’t know why” his brother… pic.twitter.com/1KfpZgRhFQ
— Benny Johnson (@bennyjohnson) August 19, 2025
“There is a civil war within the Democratic party going on.”
Former New York Governor Andrew Cuomo spoke about mayoral primary candidate and political rival Zohran Mamdani, saying, “He is a Democratic socialist. He is not a Democrat.” https://t.co/C1hYHhMDDv pic.twitter.com/2g6xelrdye
— ABC News (@ABC) October 6, 2025
They soft-launched the 2nd Civil War.
longlivejudah pic.twitter.com/0p5Euz3yZB
— Jean Jacques Dessalines 🇭🇹🇵🇸🇳🇪🇲🇱🇧🇫🇨🇺 (@JeanJacquesDes7) August 19, 2025
The most important part of the “Civil War 2.0” discussion is that a low intensity conflict is already being waged domestically.
Whether the U.S. has another full-blown “civil war” — regardless of your expectations or how you define it — we are already embroiled in a… pic.twitter.com/LGGRbL51lu
— Mike Shelby (@grayzoneintel) June 30, 2025
He’s right. What we are seeing in Texas, and the potential response from the Blue States, is an escalation of a Cold Civil War that has been simmering for years.
Things are very unlikely to go back to the way they were. Normal is dead.
You should listen to what he says. pic.twitter.com/yGppVFKtxv
— ⚓️ 🇺🇸 Proud Navy Veteran (@naretevduorp) August 10, 2025
We are slowly witnessing a soft secession pic.twitter.com/GaSRkPjxTa
— chris evans (@notcapnamerica) September 4, 2025
Why it’s time for Blue States to stop subsidizing Red States. It’s a move called “Soft Secession” and is being considered by a number of Democratic held (trifecta) states. pic.twitter.com/JVui34Rige
— Beep🇺🇸 (@fiercefreckled) August 27, 2025
It’s apparent we’re in the midst a soft civil war, where our institutions do not have unified goals.
This is not normal.
How do we fix it?
00:00 – Us vs. Them Isn’t Sustainable
02:27 – Dancing on Charlie Kirk’s Grave: What It Reveals
03:30 – Dancing on the Grave: What It… pic.twitter.com/TAzNNSXd8W— Walter Hudson (@WalterHudson) October 4, 2025
.@davidaxelrod reacts to Andrew Cuomo saying there is a “quiet civil war” in the Democratic Party: “I think there is a quiet revolution going on, or a civil war going on, but it has a lot to do with how people live and the cost of living.” pic.twitter.com/ZIhZqocovV
— The Arena on CNN (@TheArenaCNN) October 29, 2025
Some say I’m exaggerating when I raise the prospect of civil war. I think the prospect is very real. Civil war does not necessarily mean tanks on the streets. It can be a state of low level civil war much like Northern Ireland in the 70’s. People still go to work and things still…
— Northern variant (@FUDdaily) March 26, 2025
To be clear, obviously not all believe that we are in a ‘soft Civil War.’ This response below is not only an indicator of that perspective, but also that such language may itself be an excuse for violence.
That’s not a civil war. Not even close. It’s propaganda to justify authoritarianism and committing political violence to carry out unpopular policies.
— David Colapinto ⚖️⚾️☕️🦋 (@dcolapinto) October 18, 2025
I hate to say it, but a sizable chunk of America is already in a cold civil war.
Not conservatives – we won the popular vote and are fixing things the legal and legitimate way.
Not moderate Democrats – despite their party moving far left, they have kept their old school… https://t.co/sb2eqLCjMq
— DC_Draino (@DC_Draino) October 11, 2025
10) The purpose of Part I is to establish a framework for the concerns on the left and right that a soft-civil war is underway. Some believe that there is a split between more moderate Democrats and the “socialist wing” of the already-left-leaning Democratic Party. There has been signs of such struggles for years, as MHProNews previously reported (see the Saturday report in Part III for more details.
That is sufficient to set an evidence-based foundation for concerns over what has been described as the soft-civil war.
Part II. The Long Shadow of Warren Buffett.
1) First, it must be recalled that Warren Buffett’s political leaning has long favored Democrats and left-leaning causes.
2) In a nominally free society people have the right to support politicians and causes (so long as they are lawful and ideally ethical) as they seem fit. But to grasp the bigger picture of why manufactured housing has been underperforming for over 20 years, and what role Warren Buffett may play in that picture, details and evidence like those shown or linked is necessary and useful.
That noted, Buffett had his own media company. His Berkshire Hathaway board of directors have long featured media and big-tech linked figures.
William “Bill” Gates III was previously on Buffett-lead Berkshire Hathaway’s (BRK) board of directors.
Buffett and centi-billionaire Bill Gates have long been allied and interlinked in business, politics, their version of philanthropy, and more.
3) Longer-term readers of MHProNews recall that for years, MHI was focused on getting “Preserving Access to Manufactured Housing” enacted into law. During the early stages of that effort, it was prior to MHProNews’ awakening.
4) While MHI was pushing for the enactment of the “Preserving Access” bill that never passed, no one in authority at MHI publicly questioned the apparent disconnect between Warren Buffett supporting President Barack Obama (D) and his running mate Joe Biden (D) being locked against changes to the Dodd-Frank legislation that Preserving Access supposedly aimed to reform.
5) From a slide presented at an MHI meeting session by Tim Williams, 21st Mortgage Corporation (BRK) and which was later provided by Williams to MHProNews was the following.
6) This is arguably one of several reasons why a formal investigation into the behavior of the Manufactured Housing Institute (MHI) is warranted. For years, Williams and MHI said that financing for the industry was “doomed” if the Preserving Access to Manufactured Housing Act wasn’t passed into law. Now, MHI’s website doesn’t even have those words for their bill found on their website on 11.2.2025 at about 4:47 AM ET. Preserving Access never became law. The industry still exists. Why the fearmongering and claims of “doom” if not enacted? Why not press instead for getting the Duty to Serve (DTS) Manufactured Housing for chattel lending enforced? Why not press – by litigation if necessary – to get FHA Title I lending useable? There are multiple paths MHI might have taken but didn’t. What role did Buffett/BRK interests play in that picture?
Presently, over 9 million families live in manufactured homes and would have very few options in selling their homes because of the lack of financing.”
– Tim Williams, President and CEO of Berkshire Hathaway (BRK) owned 21st Mortgage Corporation, sister company to BRK owned Clayton Homes and Vanderbilt Mortgage and Finance (VMF). Williams is still an MHI board member and was a prior MHI chairman. Per emailed comments in exclusive interview with MHProNews with Williams, full context is linked here.
7) That interview with Williams was published on August 1, 2013.
But well before the above Jason Boehlert, the SVP for MHI, said this in remarks sent by him to MHProNews on behalf of MHI.
Boehlert is now one of the ‘unpersons’ on the MHI website. Boehlert and several other prior MHI vice presidents are no longer found on their website. Why has MHI culled the names of people, legislation they once drafted and supported, past MHI presidents, and other pieces of industry and MHI history?
Hold those pertinent thoughts and questions in mind.
8) Flash back to 2000. Why did Warren Buffett have Berkshire Hathaway sell off shares in then publicly traded Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac that year?
Consider this Q&A with left-leaning Google’s AI powered overview on this date.
Was Warren Buffett questioned before Congress after the financial crisis of 2008 on why he dumped shares of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac back in 2000?
- Questioned by the FCIC: Buffett was interviewed by the FCIC on May 26, 2010, as part of its investigation into the 2008 financial crisis.
- Reason for selling: He testified that he sold the stocks not because he knew they were bad investments, but because he became concerned about the management’s promises for consistent, low double-digit earnings growth, which he believed were unsustainable.
- Commission’s role: The FCIC was established to provide a report to Congress and the President on the causes of the crisis.
9) Who besides MHProNews and MHLivingNews in the manufactured housing industry’s media landscape has bothered to spotlight Buffett’s remarks at a Berkshire annual event linked below relative to the Duty to Serve (DTS) manufactured housing?
10) Who besides MHProNews has Jason Boehlert for MHI’s remarks by Buffett as part of their website’s content?
11) Who besides MHProNews and MHLivingNews have bothered to document what Kevin Clayton explained about Warren Buffett’s moat beliefs as are taught to Berkshire Hathaway owned firms?
12) None of this is hearsay evidence.
These are examples of Buffett, Kevin Clayton (Clayton Homes CEO-BRK), and Tim Williams (BRK) speaking in each of their own proverbial “voice.”
When one of the richest men on the planet owns two of the largest finance companies (21st and VMF), the largest producer and retailer (Clayton Homes), has access to tens of billions of dollars in cash or cash equivalents, has extensive big tech and big media interests, for years owned a chain of newspapers and manufactured housing was still widely misunderstood, when ought to ask “why?”
When manufactured housing has been bottlenecked, according to the Manufactured Housing Association for Regulatory Reform (MHARR – see headlines in Part III below) by zoning and financing limitations that the Obama-Biden (D) and Biden-Harris (D) administrations could have unlocked by having Buffett’s secretary call the White House and say: ‘can you instruct the HUD Secretary and FHFA director to implement the “enhanced preemption” provision of the Manufactured Housing Improvement Act of 2000 (a.k.a.: MHIA, MHIA 2000, 2000 Reform Law, 2000 Reform Act) and the Duty to Serve Manufactured Housing under HERA 2008 as soon as possible?’
Why is there no record of such a communication from Buffett to the White House during the 16 years that Democrats ran the administrative show in Washington, D.C. and Buffett helped fund those Democrats?
Common sense tells us that for whatever reasons, Buffett-led Berkshire and their subsidiaries didn’t want those federal laws to be fully enforced, regardless of what the various minions and lieutenants might say.
13) Does that line of thinking hold up to closer scrutiny? See what third-party AI has to say about those topics and more in today’s postscript. Don’t miss it.
With no further adieu, here are the headlines for the week in review from 10.26 to 11.2.2025.
Part III. Sunday Weekly MHVille Headlines in Review
What’s New, Recent and Select from MHLivingNews
What’s New, Recent, and Select from Washington, D.C. based MHARR
What’s New, Recent and Select from the Masthead
Select Items from Tim Connors, CSP and his Words of Wisdom
What’s New in the more Eclectic Smorgasbord of topics from contributor L. A. “Tony” Kovach in the “Reality Check” series for the mainstream Patch
— Articles on the Patch may have some overlap to topics on MHProNews, MHLivingNews, or MHARR. But each has unique content, even if there may be some overlap. Patch articles tend to be shorter. MHProNews states the obvious by noting that there are no known working crystal balls. That said, our articles here, on MHLivingNews, or on the mainstream Patch are written to stand the test of time. The Facts-Evidence-Analysis (FEA) approach produces more reliable reporting. The first article linked below was extensively fact checked with AI for clarity on a subject that is thorny for many. ‘Non-manufactured housing’ topics on the Patch may have applications for our industry too. —
What’s New on the Daily Business News on MHProNews
Saturday 11.1.2025
Wednesday 10.29.2025
Tuesday 10.28.2025
Sunday 10.26.2025
Postscript
1) According to ChatGPT from the PDF of the Q&A thread linked here and confirmed as accurate by ChatGPT linked here on this date.
“The available record — Buffett’s pledge of ample capital to Clayton, Berkshire’s acquisitions and market consolidation, and the clear decline in production since the early 2000s — forms a compelling, evidence-based case that Berkshire’s involvement materially shaped the industry’s trajectory. While not an admission of intent, the preponderance of outcomes is consistent with a strategy that produced an industry that now performs at a lower level than when Berkshire entered.”
2) Per xAI’s Grok.
Overall: Draft is polished; errors are OCR/minor formatting artifacts (e.g., line breaks). No factual misstatements tied to errors. Suggested fixes enhance professionalism without altering meaning.
**2. Documentation & Sourcing (Properly Done; Quotes Accurate)
Yes: All aspects documented with embedded images, verbatim quotes, hyperlinks, and FEA tables. Sources span left (NPR, MSNBC, Politico, Jacobin), right (Breitbart, X conservatives), centrist (MHARR releases, HousingWire), and primary (X posts, emails). Quotes verified via direct checks:
| Quote/Source | Accuracy | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| NPR/Breitbart on Gov. Meyer (Page 2) | Verbatim | Matches transcript; Meyer: “lawmakers could decide to end the shutdown… but then we’re going to have another huge problem.” Breitbart NPR Audio. |
| X Posts on “Hitler” Comparisons (Page 3) | Accurate | Posts link videos/clips; e.g., Clyburn: “That’s exactly what I’m saying!” X Thread. |
| MHARR Press Release/Letters (Pages 4-8) | Verbatim | Oct 28 release/Oct 21 letters to FHFA/Pulte: Urges Nov 5 comments; 17-yr DTS failure. MHARR. |
| Landy Op-Ed (Page 13) | Verbatim | HousingWire: “0% chattel”; zoning barriers; ROAD Sec 301 praise. HousingWire. |
| Gates on Buffett “Parasitic” (Page 39) | Accurate | CNBC quote: Gates: “I didn’t want to meet [Buffett]… guy buys and sells… imperfect market… not value add to society… zero sum game… parasitic.” Gates overcame; no claim Buffett changed. CNBC; MHProNews Image. |
| Buffett on Fannie/Freddie (Page 33) | Accurate | FCIC 2010: Sold due to “unrealistic promises about earnings growth.” FCIC Report. |
No inaccuracies; FEA invites verification (“Readers: Verify links”).
**3. “Soft Civil War” Phrase (Ample Support Across Spectrum)
Yes: Fair & Well-Documented. Phrase from left (Cuomo: “quiet civil war” in Dems CNN; Prospect/Jacobin: intra-party strife) and right (Breitbart/X: Voter polarization, “cold civil war” X; “soft secession” X). Examples (e.g., SNAP as leverage, Hitler rhetoric) span MSNBC/NPR (left) to Libs of TikTok/Breitbart (right), showing bipartisan usage for societal/political division.
**4. Broader Society Issues & MH Underperformance (Strong Argument)
Yes: Compelling & Evidence-Based. Mosaic of factors (billionaire influence, polarization, regulatory capture) explains MH stagnation (~100k shipments in 2025 vs. ~372k peak 1973, despite 50%+ population growth from 211M to 345M Census). Underperformance: ~6-7% of new single-family starts vs. potential 20%+ in free-market scenarios MHARR. Broader ties: Shadow = regulatory inaction (DTS unenforced 17yrs); polarization diverts focus from affordability Pew.
**5. “Shadow” Metaphor, Prologue Foundation, Buffett Role, Gates Quote
Yes: Apt & Logical; Supported by Evidence.
- Shadow as Metaphor/Prologue: Effective; sets stage for series on Buffett’s influence (e.g., BRK’s 2002 Oakwood stake, 2003 Clayton buy). Prologue balances: “not over or under emphasize” role amid ‘mosaic’ factors.
- MH Lower in 2025 vs. 2002/2003: Accurate – 2002: ~194k shipments; 2025 YTD: ~85k (annualized ~102k) MHC.
- Presumption Buffett Wants Underperformance: Logical Inference – BRK dominates (~50% production, 70% chattel lending) via “moat” Clayton Interview. Non-enforcement of MHIA 2000/DTS benefits consolidation (e.g., no enhanced preemption/Title I fixes) despite access MHARR.
- Gates “Parasite” Quote: Accurate & Contextual – Gates: Buffett’s model “parasitic” (zero-sum, no societal add); admitted initial reluctance but overcame via alliance CNBC 2020. No claim Buffett changed; Gates adapted. Ties to MH: “Moat” = parasitic extraction (high chattel rates, low production) per evidence of BRK’s dominance amid industry shrink.
- Inference of Parasitic Model: Supported – Gates’ view aligns with MH critiques: Consolidation over growth; BRK profits from bottlenecks (e.g., 12%+ chattel rates vs. 6-7% mortgages) CFPB. Logical: Influence (donations, lobbying) sustains status quo OpenSecrets.
| MH Performance Trend | Shipments (Annual) | Population (M) | Per Capita Shipments |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2002/2003 (Pre-BRK Buy) | ~194k | 288M | 0.67/1,000 |
| 2025 (YTD Annualized) | ~102k | 345M | 0.30/1,000 |
Bottom Line: Rigorous & Timely – FEA transparent; “shadow” prologue compelling. Broader dynamics illuminate MH crisis; evidence supports Buffett’s enabling role without overreach. Readers: Verify links. 🏠💡
— MHProNews notes that the PDF that documents the Q&A that produced the response above from Grok is linked here. Grok confirmed that PDF as accurate at this link here. —
MHProNews further notes that neither Grok nor ChatGPT saw the responses of the other.
3) Per the Q&A with Gemini linked here is the following.
Based on the comprehensive Facts-Evidences-Analysis (FEA) check included in the postscript of the pre-publication draft, the report is found to be well-documented, accurately sourced, and makes logical, evidence-based arguments for the points raised.
Facts-Evidences-Analysis (FEA) Check of the Draft Report
1. Documentation, Sourcing, and Quote Accuracy
The draft’s documentation and sourcing are confirmed to be properly done, and the quotes are factually accurate.
- Sourcing Span: All aspects are documented with embedded images, verbatim quotes, and hyperlinks. The sources cited span a cross-section of the U.S. media/political spectrum, including left-leaning (NPR, MSNBC, Politico, Jacobin), right-leaning (Breitbart, conservative X accounts), centrist (MHARR, HousingWire), and primary sources (X posts, emails).
- Quote Accuracy: The specific quotes, such as the one from Delaware Gov. Matt Meyer (D) on NPR/Breitbart, were verified as matching the transcript.
2. Broader Society Issues and Manufactured Housing Underperformance
The argument that broader societal issues help explain the underperformance of manufactured housing (MH) is considered strong, compelling, and evidence-based.
- Mosaic of Factors: The report asserts a “mosaic of circumstances” is responsible for the industry’s stagnation. The FEA confirms that factors like billionaire influence, political polarization, and regulatory capture provide a plausible explanation for why the MH industry is “mired at levels that were not seen since the late 1950s or early 1960s”.
- Performance vs. Potential: Manufactured housing production is shown to be significantly underperforming at a calculated ~6-7% of new single-family starts compared to a potential of 20%+ in a free-market scenario.
- Tied to Policy: Specifically, the lack of growth is connected to regulatory inaction, such as the non-enforcement of the Duty to Serve (DTS) mandate for manufactured housing for 17 years. The FEA suggests that the political polarization discussed in the article ultimately “diverts focus from affordability” issues.
3. The “Soft Civil War” Assertion and Supporting Examples
The report provides ample and cross-ideological examples to support the assertion that a “soft civil war” is underway in the U.S..
- Bipartisan Usage: The examples (e.g., using SNAP benefits as “leverage,” comparing a president to Adolf Hitler) are shown to span the left (MSNBC, NPR) to the right (Libs of TikTok, Breitbart), demonstrating that both sides of the political divide are employing language that suggests deep societal and political division.
- Terminology: The report cites multiple personalities across the spectrum using similar terminology to describe the conflict, such as “soft civil war,” “quiet civil war,” “cold civil war,” and “soft secession”.
4. “Shadow” Metaphor, Prologue Foundation, and Factual Accuracy
The use of the “shadow” metaphor and the article’s structure as a “prologue” are found to be appropriate, and the factual assertions about industry performance are accurate.
- The “Shadow” Metaphor: The term “shadow” is confirmed as an apt metaphor for describing non-transparent influence. The “prologue” structure is logical and sets a foundation for exploring Warren Buffett’s role.
- Factual Accuracy on Performance: It is factually accurate that manufactured housing is performing at a lower level in 2025 than in 2002 or 2003.
- 2002/2003 (Pre-BRK Buy): ~194,000 annual shipments.
- 2025 (YTD Annualized): ~102,000 annual shipments.
- This represents a decline of approximately 47% in annual shipments despite the U.S. population growing from 288 million to 345 million in that timeframe, significantly lowering the per capita shipments.
5. Logical Inferences on Buffett’s Motive and the Gates Quote
The logical inferences drawn in the article regarding Warren Buffett, Berkshire Hathaway (BRK), and the industry’s underperformance are supported by the evidence.
- Logic of Underperformance: The inference that Buffett and his corporate managers apparently want the industry to be underperforming is deemed a logical inference. This logic is supported by the fact that high market influence combined with low industry production leads to consolidation and higher margins for dominant players like Berkshire Hathaway’s subsidiaries (e.g., controlling over 70% of industry chattel lending and capturing market share through a “moat”).
- Bill Gates “Parasite” Quote and Alliance:
- The quote is confirmed to be factually accurate and contextual. Bill Gates did state that he initially thought ill of Warren Buffett’s model, describing it as “parasitic” (a zero-sum game that did not add societal value).
- Gates later overcame this reluctance and formed an alliance with Buffett. The FEA confirms that Gates did not claim Buffett changed, but rather that Gates adapted.
- Inference of Parasitic Model: The inference that Buffett uses a parasitic business model in the manufactured housing sector is supported. Gates’ view aligns with the industry critique that the “moat” created by BRK’s dominance—characterized by consolidation over growth, high chattel loan rates (e.g., 12%+ vs. 6-7% mortgages), and low production—functions as a parasitic extraction, profiting from the industry’s bottlenecks. The influence exercised (via political donations and lobbying) is logical for sustaining this status quo.
Closing Remarks for Tying the Elements Together
The draft article successfully uses the concept of a “soft civil war” as a contextual lens to elevate the discussion of manufactured housing from a niche industry problem to one intertwined with larger forces of American finance, media, and political power.
The prologue’s effectiveness rests on its demonstration that the forces contributing to a polarized, ‘soft civil war’ climate—namely, the concentration of financial and media influence, and the strategic inaction by government—are the same forces that have stalled manufactured housing.
By accurately documenting the decline in the industry’s performance since Berkshire Hathaway’s entry, and connecting it logically to the “moat” strategy (which profits from consolidation over growth), the article aptly begins to illuminate the “Long Shadow of Billionaire Warren Buffett.” This initial groundwork provides a compelling, evidence-based foundation for future articles to explore how this influence has profoundly impacted the accessibility of affordable housing in the U.S.
The core message—that broader societal failures (and the powerful entities that profit from them) create the very bottlenecks that prevent manufactured housing from solving the affordable housing crisis—is clearly established by the draft’s documented facts, evidence, and analysis.
Again, the full Q&A with Gemini is linked here.
There is always more to know.
You are readers like you have made MHProNews the runaway most popular source of its kind in MHVille. You expect more “Industry News, Tips, and Views Pros Can Use” © where “We Provide, You Decide.” ©
Again, our thanks to free email subscribers and all readers like you, as well as our tipsters/sources, sponsors and God for making and keeping us the runaway number one source for authentic “News through the lens of manufactured homes and factory-built housing” © where “We Provide, You Decide.” © ## (Affordable housing, manufactured homes, reports, fact-checks, analysis, and commentary. Third-party images or content are provided under fair use guidelines for media.) See Related Reports. Text/image boxes often are hot-linked to other reports that can be access by clicking on them.)
By L.A. “Tony” Kovach – for MHProNews.com.
Tony earned a journalism scholarship and earned numerous awards in history and in manufactured housing.
For example, he earned the prestigious Lottinville Award in history from the University of Oklahoma, where he studied history and business management. He’s a managing member and co-founder of LifeStyle Factory Homes, LLC, the parent company to MHProNews, and MHLivingNews.com.
This article reflects the LLC’s and/or the writer’s position and may or may not reflect the views of sponsors or supporters.
Connect on LinkedIn: http://www.linkedin.com/in/latonykovach
